Berlin failed to warn the navy, federal police or counter-terrorism agencies about a potential sabotage act, Der Spiegel has said

Germany had received several warnings from other Western intelligence services, including the CIA, about a supposed Ukrainian attack on the Nord Stream gas pipelines some three months before the incident, Der Spiegel reported on Wednesday. Berlin simply dismissed that information as “wrong” and failed to react in time, the media outlet said.

Several Western intelligence services had allegedly been informed by a Swedish agent that a sabotage operation was being prepared as early as June 2022, according to Der Spiegel. Germany’s Federal Intelligence Service (BND) received encrypted messages from its foreign colleagues, including the Dutch agency and the CIA, the same month, the paper said.

The warnings contained very specific details about the impending attack, the German magazine said, citing sources familiar with the matter. According to Der Spiegel, the BND was told that at least six Ukrainian commandos with false IDs were planning “to rent a vessel, dive down to the pipelines at the bottom of the Baltic Sea with special equipment and blow them up.”

Read more

The operation was greenlit by Ukraine’s then-top military commander, General Valery Zaluzhny, the warnings reportedly said, adding that the attack was scheduled for the time of the NATO BALTOPS maritime drills, which were to be held in the Baltic Sea on June 5-17, 2022.

According to Der Spiegel, the BND only passed the information to Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s office after the drills had ended. The German government considered the information “irrelevant” since nothing had happened during the maneuvers, the paper said. “At that time, a predominant view in the bureaucratic security circles was that the information was wrong,” Der Spiegel reported, citing officials familiar with the warnings.

“Despite the warnings, no preparations were made on the German side to prevent a possible attack at a later date. The federal police, the Navy and the federal and regional counterterrorism authorities were not informed,” the magazine said.

Berlin launched a criminal probe into the incident after the pipelines were damaged in late September 2022. The German authorities have yet to provide any official information on the probe. In August, German media reported that law enforcement officials had issued a first arrest warrant in the case, allegedly for a Ukrainian national identified as “Vladimir Z.” According to Der Spiegel, the man was one of the divers who took part in the operation.

Read more

Berlin’s silence on the matter drew some criticism from the country’s opposition. German left-wing politician and MP Sahra Wagenknecht, who leads her own party – the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), questioned what she called Berlin’s ongoing “deafening silence” a full two years after the September 2022 incident. Such actions on the government’s part raise even more questions, she said at that time, calling for an independent parliamentary inquiry into the matter.

Moscow has dismissed reports linking a small Ukrainian team to the sabotage as implausible. Last month, Danish media revealed that US Navy warships were operating near the Nord Stream pipelines shortly before the blasts.

Skepticism about the ‘small Ukrainian team’ narrative persists in Germany as well. A renowned German diving expert, Dr. Sven Thomas, questioned a small team’s ability to launch the large-scale attack earlier this month. Military-grade bottom mines with a yield equivalent to 1,260 kilograms of TNT were needed for explosions of such magnitude, he argued. Planting such devices, he said, would have necessitated a large vessel, not the yacht reportedly used.